• Home
  • Heat Recovery Ventilation System Pros and Cons

Heat Recovery Ventilation System Pros and Cons

Heat Recovery Ventilation System Pros and Cons

As homes become more airtight for energy efficiency, ventilation without sacrificing comfort has become a priority. Heat Recovery Ventilation (HRV) systems are a solution – fresh air flow is maintained while saving energy. For anyone who has ever considered an HRV system but is unsure of its merits and drawbacks, this heat recovery ventilation system pros and cons guide will help you make an informed decision.

What is a Heat Recovery Ventilation (HRV) System?

A Heat Recovery ventilation (HRV) system provides fresh air with low energy loss. It pulls stale air from indoors, recovers heat from it and uses that energy to warm the coming fresh air. HRV systems provide healthy indoor airflow and humidity balance.

The Pros: Heat Recovery Ventilation System

  1. Energy Efficiency: HRV systems consume little electricity. Transferring heat to incoming air reduces your heating or cooling loads. Such a move can cut your energy bills dramatically in extreme seasons.
  2. Improved Indoor Air Quality: An HRV system changes stale indoor air with filtered air. This removes pollutants, allergens and excess humidity for a healthier indoor environment.
  3. Humidity Control: Where high humidity is high, HRV systems prevent dampness, mould and mildew by maintaining a balanced humidity indoors. This is useful in tightly sealed homes where moisture can collect.
  4. Consistent Temperature Control: HRV systems preheat incoming air to maintain a consistent indoor temperature. Especially in winter when cold outdoor air can create drafts.
  5. Reduced Carbon Footprint: Using less energy saves money and reduces your home carbon emissions. An HRV system is a green option for homeowners wanting to reduce their carbon footprint.
  6. Silent Operation: The modern HRV systems are silent and will not disturb your everyday activities – while keeping your office air fresh and comfortable!

The Cons: Heat Recovery Ventilation System

  1. High Initial Cost: Installing an HRV system is expensive. The equipment itself and professional installation are a substantial upfront investment. Yet the savings on energy bills long term often outweigh that expense as well.
  2. Maintenance Requirements: Heat recovery ventilation systems need regular maintenance. Filters need to be cleaned or replaced, and the system inspected for airflow blockages or mechanical problems periodically.
  3. Very Limited Heat Recovery in Extreme Cold Climates: Areas with harsh winters may have poorer HRV systems. Other heating solutions might still be needed, increasing energy consumption.
  4. Space Requirements: HRV systems need dedicated space for installation. This is a challenge in smaller homes or apartments.
  5. Not a Replacement for Air Conditioning: HRV systems provide ventilation and heat recovery but no cooling. In hotter climates, an energy recovery ventilation system (ERV) that moderates humidity might be a better option.

Energy Recovery Ventilation System Pros and Cons

If you are also considering Energy Recovery Ventilation – ERV – see also how ERV differs from HRV. An ERV can recover heat plus moisture so is more appropriate in humid climates. Here is a comparison of energy recovery ventilation pros and cons:

Pros

  • Ideal for humid climates because it controls heat and moisture.
  • Prevents too dry indoor air – a problem common to HRV systems – from occurring.
  • Energy saving benefits similar to HRV systems.

Cons

  • A little more expensive than HRV systems.
  • May be less effective in extremely cold or dry climates.

HRV vs. ERV: Which Ventilation System is Right for You?

Aspect

Heat Recovery Ventilation (HRV)

Energy Recovery Ventilation (ERV)

Primary Function

Transfers heat from outgoing air to incoming air for efficiency.

Transfers heat and moisture for efficiency and humidity control.

Best for Climate

Cold or temperate climates with low to moderate humidity levels.

Humid climates where moisture control is crucial.

Energy Efficiency

High, as it reduces heating and cooling costs.

High, with added benefit of moisture balance.

Humidity Control

Limited, can make indoor air dry in winter.

Balances indoor humidity, preventing excess dryness.

Cost

Lower upfront cost compared to ERV systems.

Slightly higher upfront cost due to additional functionality.

Maintenance

Requires regular filter cleaning and occasional inspections.

Requires similar maintenance but may need additional checks for moisture.

Installation Space

Needs adequate space for equipment and ducting.

Similar space requirements as HRV systems.

Suitability for Cold Climates

Works well, but additional heating might be needed in extreme cold.

Less efficient in cold climates, especially if dry air isn’t a concern.

Suitability for Hot Climates

Less effective for managing humidity in hot, humid conditions.

Effective in hot, humid conditions due to moisture recovery.

Environmental Impact

Reduces carbon footprint by lowering energy use.

Similar environmental benefits with added moisture control.

Should You Invest in a Heat Recovery Ventilation System?

When choosing an HRV versus an ERV, consider your local climate, home size and budget. In a temperate or cold climate where humidity control is not a major concern, an HRV system is a good choice for comfort and energy efficiency. For humid regions however an ERV may be more appropriate.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Ventilation Solution for Your Home

Knowing the heat recovery ventilation system pros and cons will help you decide if it’s right for your home. The initial costs are high, but the energy savings, better indoor air quality and consistent comfort mean HRV systems are a smart investment for many homeowners.

Here at Hamilton Air Conditioning, we install and maintain advanced HRV/ ERV systems. We’ll help you pick the best ventilation solution for your home. Call today to discuss your needs and get custom HVAC solutions for your place.

Matthew Connery
By: Matthew Connery

Matthew Connery is the Director of Hamilton Air Conditioning in London. He is a skilled Business Strategist who delivers energy-efficient and cost-saving solutions to commercial and domestic clients from leading air conditioning brands. 

Jan 17 2025